For me giving someone a rating of 4 after bing involved in an away win was too harsh. So let’s decide a fair ratings system;

1: sent off in first 15 mins: subbed in first 15: otherwise shouldn’t be on the pitch. Nil commitment, multiple errors leading to goal being conceded and scores an oh: fighting with team mates: gives ball away continually; won’t jump for the ball and turns back on challenges.
2: sent off in first half: subbed in first half; multiple errors leading to goals conceded: shows some flair by scoring 3 OG’s; gives ball away mostly otherwise passes backwards and puts others under pressure. Won’t jump for the ball.
3: generally piss poor performance; lack of commitment in the tackle; gives the ball away to opposition almost every time he gets it; passes sideways and backwards putting teammates under pressure; goalie poor game and punches ball in to own net;
4: missing for long periods of the game; weak in the tackle; multiple errors leading to opposition pressure or goals; passes sideways and finds a team mate once in a blue moon. Hits first defender with every shot, clearance corner or free kick.
5: bang average performance; for every positive there’s a negative and there is a cheer when he is subbed
6: marginally above average; shows some positive aspects to play which outweigh the negatives; defends well enough and jumps to challenge for the ball
7; good performance; wins challenges; uses ball well; scores or assists; keeper saves pen or multiple saves; lifts crowd; goal line clearance;
8; great game; wants the ball; wins the ball; uses and distributes well; scores or wins pen; multiple assists; keeper saves pen or multiple saves; keeper catches crosses well;
9; tremendous game; mom level performance; does everything right; scores two; wins a penalty; multiple assists; keeper saves pen or multiple saves and sets up goal; goal line clearance;
10; outstanding game as per 8; but there is just that something extra; it could just be exceptional skill; it could be getting an opponent sent off; lifting the crowd with bursts of energy and speed; scoring a hat trick or an exceptional last minute winner; a defender getting a hat trick; a keeper saves two pens;

Etc. Generally speaking you shouldn’t get less than a 6 for a win or four for a draw; anything goes for a defeat.