The real match ratings

Obafemi Obsession · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 4:29 pm

Ok Stoke were awful and they played to our strengths. And given the first half was awful. But:

ALB: Nowt to do - 6.
Sweeney: Injured - 6.
Humps: Good and bad - 7.
Nelson: Immense, absolutely immense. And a goal - 10.
Collins: Solid - 8.
Jones: Lots of graft - 7.
Robson: Just gets better and better - 9.
Liddle: Just got better and better - 8.
Clark: Reliable - 8.
Porter: Ran his socks off - 8.
Mackay : Injured - 6.

Subs: Foley: Out of this worl strike - 8.
McCunnie: Steady away - 6.

Well done lads!

tREE_wiTH_hAMStER · **Joined:** Sat May 19, 2007 11:00 am **Posts:** 20758

ALB-7.
Sweens-6
Humps-5
Collins-9
Nelson-9
Jones-8
Liddle 6.5
Clark-7.5
Robson-8.5
Porter-7.5
Mckay-5

Foley-8
Mccunnie-6.5

monkeehanger · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:08 pm

ALB - 7 (Well protected by the defence though).
Sweeney - 6
Humps - 7
Collins - 8
Nelson - 7 (9 2nd half)
Jones - 8
Liddle - 7
Clark - 8
Robson - 9
Porter - 6
Mckay - 5

Foley - 8
Mccunnie-7

joe allon's false teeth · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:49 pm

I agree with them all but i dont think jones deserves an 8

Hangem · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:55 pm

joe allon's false teeth wrote:

I agree with them all but i dont think jones deserves an 8

yeah it should have been a 10 rolfl

Jonny · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 5:58 pm

All players did well today, ALB wasn't tested thankfully.....

Obafemi Obsession · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 6:01 pm

joe allon's false teeth wrote:

I agree with them all but i dont think jones deserves an 8

That's why I gave him a seven.

scotty-pools10 · **Joined:** Mon Jul 28, 2008 9:49 pm **Posts:** 178

No one apart from sweeney and mackay derseves lower than a 7

Nelson, Collins, Robson all worthy of 9/10

Everyone else was either good or solid clappp

tigro · **Posted:** Sat Jan 03, 2009 6:30 pm

at the end of the day, all the players who played deserved a 10 today for beating stoke.

Mr Irrelevant · **Joined:** Thu Aug 17, 2006 8:25 pm **Posts:** 22665

ALB: Nowt to do - 6
Sweeney: for the time he was on 7.
Humps: Consistantly gave the ball away but a couple of decent challenges - 6.
Nelson: The Nelson of old- 10.
Collins: Played well even a decent cameo in attack- 9.
Jones: did ok - 7.
Robson: Robson and foley scared them to death - 9.
Liddle: good solid game - 8.
Clark: Worked very hard all game. Solid - 8.
Porter: Some great touches better than the majority of their premier league players - 8.
Mackay : looked out of his depth until injured - 6.
Foley: See Robson and that goal! - 9.
McCunnie: Did well with what little he had to do - 7.

gremmlin · **Joined:** Fri Oct 05, 2007 9:23 am **Posts:** 3141

Mr I wrote:

ALB: Nowt to do - 6
Sweeney: for the time he was on 7.
Humps: Consistantly gave the ball away but a couple of decent challenges - 6.
Nelson: The Nelson of old- 10.
Collins: Played well even a decent cameo in attack- 9.
Jones: did ok - 7.
Robson: Robson and foley scared them to death - 9.
Liddle: good solid game - 8.
Clark: Worked very hard all game. Solid - 8.
Porter: Some great touches better than the majority of their premier league players - 8.
Mackay : looked out of his depth until injured - 6.
Foley: See Robson and that goal! - 9.
McCunnie: Did well with what little he had to do - 7.

you seen all of that through one eye? :laugh:

humps did well then as he usually starts with a minus eight from you

Mr Irrelevant · **Joined:** Thu Aug 17, 2006 8:25 pm **Posts:** 22665

gremmlin wrote:

humps did well then as he usually starts with a minus eight from you

Just as I seen it Mr M. I thought he made a couple of very good tackles but his positioning is poor and there was a spell in the second half that most touch ended up with a Stoke player. Either way, today is not a day to get into a this sort of debate so I'll bow to your years and give him a seven.

The real match ratings

Gadgies online