Player of the year up to now

poolieinnottingham · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 9:26 pm

Maybe it's just a knee-jerk to the lack of keeper over the previous two seasons, but I reckon Flinders is the man. Liddle and Collins have improved loads (probably due in part to him marshalling them well), but Flinders has been consistently good in my opinion.

Tax Paying Poolie · **Joined:** Sat Aug 19, 2006 8:18 am **Posts:** 9053

poolieinnottingham wrote:

Maybe it's just a knee-jerk to the lack of keeper over the previous two seasons, but I reckon Flinders is the man. Liddle and Collins have improved loads (probably due in part to him marshalling them well), but Flinders has been consistently good in my opinion.

Austin for me.

Flinders has been consistently good but I think Austin has put in more 'excellent' performances. I'd also put Liddle ahead of Flinders. Flinders on the whole has had little to do although that doesn't mean I don't think he has been seriously good.

katcha · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 9:53 pm

flinders phil man ..... :roll:

derwent · **Joined:** Wed Jun 24, 2009 7:59 pm **Posts:** 12375

Austin

TalbotAvenger · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 10:09 pm

ElvisAintDead wrote:

Flinders is quality, top-notch in fact, but I prefer Austin to be magnificent as it winds Loids up.

I fully agree

misterb2001 · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 10:14 pm

Flinders has done very well, but a massive part of that has been the 4 people in front of him being so solid.

its bloody difficult to pick from Flinders, Austin, Collins or Liddle.

Liddle has been great although 1 or 2 mistakes have lead to goals. Austin has been fantastic as has Flinders, but for me my MOM has been Sam Collins.

After the slagging off he has got over the last 18 month, he has been a Captain and a half for me. Absolutely outstanding, the bloke just doesn't lose headers.

Although it probably should be given to the back 5 as a whole!

tREE_wiTH_hAMStER · **Joined:** Sat May 19, 2007 11:00 am **Posts:** 20758

Would give it to Collins or Liddle myself mainly due to them being ever present where as Austin never featured for first 5 or 6 games??

Gibsons Beard · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 11:32 pm

misterb2001 wrote:

Flinders has done very well, but a massive part of that has been the 4 people in front of him being so solid.

its bloody difficult to pick from Flinders, Austin, Collins or Liddle.

Liddle has been great although 1 or 2 mistakes have lead to goals. Austin has been fantastic as has Flinders, but for me my MOM has been Sam Collins.

After the slagging off he has got over the last 18 month, he has been a Captain and a half for me. Absolutely outstanding, the bloke just doesn't lose headers.

Although it probably should be given to the back 5 as a whole!

I concur.

misterb2001 · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 11:34 pm

Grave wrote:

misterb2001 wrote:

I love Richie Humphreys and want his babies. He is THE best EVER player in the world ever.

I concur.

Jonny · **Posted:** Tue Nov 17, 2009 11:50 pm

Flinders for me so far.....

Mr Ripper · **Posted:** Wed Nov 18, 2009 8:39 am

Ritchie Humphreys? :shock:

Snowy · **Joined:** Fri Aug 18, 2006 12:18 pm **Posts:** 37731

chip fireball wrote:

collins has certainly been the most improved player from last season. many fans ( this one included ) felt he was ready for the scrap heap, but he has been excellent. his marvellous headed goal-line clearance on saturday was overlooked by most on here, but it was a piece of superb defending.

Agree, maybe the trouble with Collins in the past has been a clash of roles with Nelson, where two similar players were competing for the same balls with neither sure of their exact role. With Nelsons departure, Collins is a different player, but to be fair, Nelson seemed as confused and hesitant as Collins when they played together.... managers eh?

Hangem · **Posted:** Wed Nov 18, 2009 11:03 am

Doesn't it make a change talking about a player of the year and no one has mentioned any forwards or midfielders just goes to show what a fantastic job the back 5 are doing and any defenders on the sidelines should be worried about trying to break into the first team..... oh and my player so far without doubt is Neil Austin with the others pushing him all the way. :)

Mr Ripper · **Posted:** Wed Nov 18, 2009 11:14 am

H99 wrote:

Doesn't it make a change talking about a player of the year and no one has mentioned any forwards or midfielders just goes to show what a fantastic job the back 5 are doing and any defenders on the sidelines should be worried about trying to break into the first team..... oh and my player so far without doubt is Neil Austin with the others pushing him all the way. :)

Hangem · **Posted:** Wed Nov 18, 2009 1:00 pm

Mr Ripper wrote:

H99 wrote:

Doesn't it make a change talking about a player of the year and no one has mentioned any forwards or midfielders just goes to show what a fantastic job the back 5 are doing and any defenders on the sidelines should be worried about trying to break into the first team..... oh and my player so far without doubt is Neil Austin with the others pushing him all the way. :)

If you really ment it I would have said other then ritchie but I know it would just turn into a ritchie bashing thread when its a decent thread as it is :D

Mr Ripper · **Posted:** Wed Nov 18, 2009 1:02 pm

Player of the year up to now

Gadgies online