Honestly when you think about it, there was very little between the two in my opinion.

Both have underachieved given the players at their disposal, both have made poor signings. To Scottys credit though, he was much less experienced than that twat Wilson. Wilson should know what he is doing but clearly hasnt got a clue.

In fact I would say that I hate Danny Wilson more right now than I ever hated Mr Chuckle.

well i am in the danny out camp and have been all season and to a certain extent last season he got lucky with a good run but even i could have got us promoted with the team we had and the division we were in
i have never been a fan of DW and seen nothing in two years to change my mind so maybe i am biased but still vote out

The fact that anybody would even contemplate having this poll gives you all the answers you need. Wilson has form when it comes to managing relegated teams. He at least should know all the signs. Scotty was just naive , mainly because IOR were also naive in appointing him and then stubbornly refusing to admit their mistake..............a bit like they are doing now. I can't believe that KH is allowing this to go on.

Wilson has bolloxed it up big style this season,last season he got lucky,but - he brought in Liddle,Monkhouse & Barker,He also got a hat-trick out of Jon Daly.There was a time when we could be heard singing 'Danny Wilsons blue & white army'.We paid our first visit to The White Elephant & walloped the Doils,so there have been good times under DW.
During Scottys time the only bright spot was a league cup win over the Doils,everything else was utter shite,he is a horrible snidey little shit.
As far as Im concerned Scotty is the most despicable little shit that has ever worked for Hartlepool United.

now your just being silly. scotty was so much worse than wilson did you forget last season ?

Scotty was fucking miles worse. Would Scotty have gotten us back up? Is he even a manager, really?

As much as I'm VERY pissed off at Wilson at the moment, last year wasn't just lucky. Plus Scott's antics were enough to get him a good hiding by Ben Clark.

as bad as each in equal measure I think

What he said.

What he said he said.

This is what I don't get about Wilson.

Last season we still had the hangover of relegation and started the season indifferently. We were struggling for goals, so he brought in Duffy on loan which started our good run, When Duffy went back he brought in Barker, a great signing to keep us pushing on. He also brought in Monkhouse, another inspired signing. The man did very little wrong last year.

Splittng the defensive partnership of Nelson/Clark was a big mistake. Not replacing Dimi with a decent keeper was another. He knew he was going.

Some of the team selections have been baffling, likewise tactics and substitutions. I know it's a better level but Wallsall, Swindon and Brizzle have all coped well. We were (apologies to the Saddlers) The best team in that Division by a country mile from Dec onwards.

He has alienated and by the looks of the performances, lost the players. The ones that count anyway.

What the hell is he playing at?

Danny Wilson has failed to see the obvious this season, he has pissed about too much with his silly selections. The team lack leadership from all directions, it really is time for the experienced players like Nelson, Boland and Barker to come to the party and raise their game to keep us in this league. It is time for Wilson to start picking the best available XI - sort it out Danny and show some fukking fight and passion.

Wilson is bad but compared to Scott he's Neale Cooper

scott was definitely a total waste of space.
but and its a gigantic but wilsons antics
have made me loathe and despise the clueless 'lovely lovely person'
more and more each day .
he lurches from one catastrophe to another and in his own deluded mind thinks he is doing a good job .

it wouldnt surprise me if he tried to change clubs badge to incorporate a fucking zimmer frame
admittedly it qwould not be out of place

the club seems to be rapidly turning into a geriatric retirement home

for his old cronies do the honourable thing now and welcome to the board